论文标题

图书馆贷款法规中的道悖论:弗林特的案例研究

Deontic Paradoxes in Library Lending Regulations: A Case Study in Flint

论文作者

Lutz, Sterre

论文摘要

Flint是Van Dosburg等人开发的一种基于框架和以动作为中心的语言。捕获和比较规范来源的不同解释(例如法律或法规)。这项研究的目的是研究Flint是否容易受到已知在规范系统中发生的悖论的影响。图书馆贷款法规的例子 - 首先是由Sergot引入的,主张在法律知识代表中列出了道义概念 - 这是该分析的核心。假设是,弗林特能够在没有武力悖论的情况下表达Sergot的图书馆示例(最值得注意的是:Chisholm Paradox)。这项研究是对Flint作为一种语言的表现力的正式分析的第一步,并进一步了解了Flint与现有的Deontic逻辑之间的关系。

Flint is a frame-based and action-centered language developed by Van Doesburg et al. to capture and compare different interpretations of sources of norms (e.g. laws or regulations). The aim of this research is to investigate whether Flint is susceptible to paradoxes that are known to occur in normative systems. The example of library lending regulations -- first introduced by Sergot to argue for including deontic concepts in legal knowledge representation -- is central to this analysis. The hypothesis is that Flint is capable of expressing Sergot's library example without the occurrence of deontic paradoxes (most notably: the Chisholm paradox). This research is a first step towards a formal analysis of the expressive power of Flint as a language and furthers understanding of the relation between Flint and existing deontic logics.

扫码加入交流群

加入微信交流群

微信交流群二维码

扫码加入学术交流群,获取更多资源