论文标题
在意大利Covid-19大流行期间的在线错误信息流动
Flow of online misinformation during the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic in Italy
论文作者
论文摘要
COVID-19大流行对每项人类活动都有影响,并且由于发现对这种前所未有的紧急情况的适当反应的紧迫性,它引起了一个扩散的社会辩论。该讨论的在线版本并未因D/错误信息运动的存在而被豁免,但与其他辩论中已经见证的Covid-19(有意或无意)的情况不同的是,虚假信息流处于严重风险中,降低了政府对抗的有效性。在本手稿中,我们研究了大流行期间意大利社会辩论中错误信息的有效影响,重点是各种话语社区。为了提取话语社区,我们专注于经过验证的用户,即由Twitter正式认证的帐户。因此,我们会根据标准验证的用户如何看待验证的用户来推断各种话语社区:如果未经验证的帐户将两个验证的帐户视为相似的帐户,我们将其链接在认证帐户网络中。我们首先观察到,除了是一个科学的主题外,Covid-19的讨论表明,结果是不同的政治团体的明确分歧。此时,通过使用常用的事实检查软件(Newsguard),我们评估了交换新闻的声誉。我们从随机噪声中过滤转发网络(即用户重新播放相同的基本信息或推文),并检查显示URL的消息的存在。由于该群体的活动,错误信息哨所的影响在右翼和中央机翼社区中达到了22.1%,其贡献在绝对数字上更加强大:政治团体共享的所有非信誉的URL中有96%来自该社区。
The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted on every human activity and, because of the urgency of finding the proper responses to such an unprecedented emergency, it generated a diffused societal debate. The online version of this discussion was not exempted by the presence of d/misinformation campaigns, but differently from what already witnessed in other debates, the COVID-19 -- intentional or not -- flow of false information put at severe risk the public health, reducing the effectiveness of governments' countermeasures. In the present manuscript, we study the effective impact of misinformation in the Italian societal debate on Twitter during the pandemic, focusing on the various discursive communities. In order to extract the discursive communities, we focus on verified users, i.e. accounts whose identity is officially certified by Twitter. We thus infer the various discursive communities based on how verified users are perceived by standard ones: if two verified accounts are considered as similar by non unverified ones, we link them in the network of certified accounts. We first observe that, beside being a mostly scientific subject, the COVID-19 discussion show a clear division in what results to be different political groups. At this point, by using a commonly available fact-checking software (NewsGuard), we assess the reputation of the pieces of news exchanged. We filter the network of retweets (i.e. users re-broadcasting the same elementary piece of information, or tweet) from random noise and check the presence of messages displaying an url. The impact of misinformation posts reaches the 22.1% in the right and center-right wing community and its contribution is even stronger in absolute numbers, due to the activity of this group: 96% of all non reputable urls shared by political groups come from this community.